Warm wood table and traditional chairs beside a divided-light window in an inviting historic-style dining room, with late-autumn foliage outside.

Bedminster Tavern Brings the Town's Name Back to Main Street's 1786 Corner

November 19, 2026

Bedminster Tavern has replaced Delicious Heights at 285 Main Street. It has a new menu, a piano, and a whiskey bar in the back room that people who went to Willie's will remember as Legends. The sign out front is new, but the name on it is an old one for this building.

Aaron Melick built a hotel here in 1786, in what was then called Lesser Crossroads, for his son John. John was coming home after serving in the Continental Army. For much of the next two centuries, the building carried the town's name. After 37 years as Willie's and then Delicious Heights, it carries the town's name again.

Two centuries of names on one corner

The local history site Mr. Local History has pieced together the building's ownership record. Its count runs to at least eight names. Here are the major names, several of which use the town's name:

  1. Bedminster Hotel, 1786. Melick builds it as the first tavern in Lesser Crossroads. Continental Army Captain William Fulkerson buys it on April 11, 1800.
  2. Bedminster House, from 1825. Peter Blair takes ownership and later sells to the Jeffkins, who give it this name.
  3. The Inn at Bedminster, 1889. By then it is a popular stop on the carriage route between Morristown and Somerville.
  4. Howard Hotel, 1898. Willie and Bertha Howard buy it for $5,000. The family's name comes off again before long, and it goes back to being the Bedminster Hotel.
  5. The Cock and Bull, 1964 to 1972. John H. Ewing of Peapack buys it and renames it.
  6. Bedminster Inn, from 1972, then "The Inn" in 1981. The town's name returns under Elias Boudinot "Bud" Fisher of Far Hills. The Kissel family later runs it as The Inn.
  7. Willie's Tavern, October 1989.
  8. Delicious Heights, 2011.

An 1873 map shows the hotel at the corner of Main Street and Hillside Avenue. A photo from around 1910 shows it as a regular stop for the stagecoach between Peapack and Somerville. Over the years it was also a polling place, a pool room, a package store, a political forum and a speakeasy.

The Howards, and the man Willie's was named for

Willie Howard is the reason so many longtime residents still call this corner "Willie's." He came to Gladstone in 1893 with Charles Pfizer to work as huntsman for what became the Essex Hunt Club. Five years later, he and Bertha bought the hotel. The Howard family owned it from 1898 to 1963, longer than any other family has.

The Howards kept it running through Prohibition. According to Mr. Local History, they made applejack in a 1,000-gallon still in nearby Chester and brewed beer and ale in the cellar. They bought their apples from Hildebrandt's farm in Oldwick, which the site says is still standing. Willie died in 1929 and is buried with Bertha in the nearby Bedminster Reformed Church cemetery.

Sixty years after his death, Willie's name went on the sign. Jack Welch's Growth Restaurants partnership of Basking Ridge bought the Inn in July 1989. After three months of renovation, it reopened that October as Willie's Taverne, in honor of Willie Howard. The same group also ran The Store in Basking Ridge and the Public House in Chester. The name lasted 22 years.

A new sign takes a while to sink in

In September 2011, the owners of Delicious Heights in Berkeley Heights opened their second location in the remodeled Willie's building. NJ.com covered the opening that November. Six years later, co-owner Ralph Aquaviva told TAPinto that the owners had redone the exterior because they realized drivers hadn't noticed the ownership had changed.

This time the new name went on the building through a public process. Mr. Local History reports that the new business went before Bedminster's Historic Preservation Commission on September 17, 2026, about signage for the property. A building this old on a corner this familiar gets its new name through the township's historic review. Choosing "Bedminster Tavern" ties the business to the building's earliest names. Calling it "Delicious Heights" didn't.

The new owner started out at the front door

Patch reported in October that owner Alyssa Cranston has worked at Delicious Heights since she was 16. She started as a greeter and server and worked her way up, while also working as catering sales manager at Bridgewater Manor. She told Patch the concept came from years of hearing what diners in the room wanted:

"I've been in this area working for a long time now. And talking to the locals when they come in and dine about what they're looking for and getting their feedback. We wanted to get away from more of the fried bar food and get more into things that made sense for Somerset County."

She described the change to Patch as a rebrand, with a new menu, new cocktails and some renovation inside. The plan is a locally sourced menu that changes each fall, winter, spring and summer. Chef Christopher Albrecht, who Cranston said previously worked with Harvest Group, runs the kitchen, and The Celtic Hospitality Group is involved in the business. The fall dinner menu posted on the tavern's site includes squash soup, pumpkin pasta and dishes made with cranberry.

The back room gets its third name

People who knew Willie's will remember Legends Sports Bar. It had its own entrance beside the main tavern and was mostly used for private parties. Now that room is The Stables, a whiskey bar. The name fits a building whose best-known owner came to the area to run hounds for the Essex Hunt Club.

According to the tavern's event page, the whiskey bar launched Thursday, October 22, with whiskey bar nights after that on Thursdays and Fridays from 7 to 11 p.m. The main room has a piano now. The tavern's site lists live music Thursday through Saturday from 7 to 10 p.m.

Before you stop in

Here are the hours posted on bedminstertavern.com:

  • Monday: closed
  • Tuesday and Wednesday: noon to 11 p.m.
  • Thursday and Friday: noon to midnight
  • Saturday: 11 a.m. to midnight
  • Sunday: 11 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.

The site says holiday and event hours may differ. With Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, call ahead at (908) 234-1596 before planning a visit around the holiday. The tavern also posts its upcoming music on its home page and on Instagram.

If you're out for the afternoon, you can follow Bedminster's Revolutionary history to the Jacobus Vanderveer House near Pluckemin's new Crossroads Park. Willie Howard's grave is in the Bedminster Reformed Church cemetery, close to the tavern.

Do you have a Willie's story, or a memory of the room before it was Legends? Karen Gray would love to hear it, along with anything else you know about Bedminster's oldest buildings. You'll find more local stories on our Bedminster Township page. Let's Connect.

Work With Karen

Working with Karen means partnering with a trusted advisor who brings market expertise, thoughtful strategy, and a client-first approach to every transaction. Known for her professionalism, attention to detail, and calm guidance, Karen ensures a seamless experience from the first conversation through closing.